The Dilemma of
Focus Lumber
Shareholders
The recent below expectation results for Q1/FY2016 (Quarter One for
Financial Year 2016) of Focus Lumber Berhad was reflected on its performance of its share
price.
The result was announced on May 21 evening after the closing market. As
such, there were a period of two days for many anxious shareholders of Focus
Lumber to discuss busily in the website of i3investor.com.
Amongst the discussions were some who predicted gloomy pictures while a
few brave heroes were defending the company, pointing out the good
fundamentals. We shall never know who will be right or wrong.
What matters is the direction of the share price. It will affect various
groups of shareholders or short term players.
So what went wrong with Focus Lumber or was that anything really wrong
with the company. I did a bit of "csi" (ha, ha, csi stands for
criminal scene investigation, actually). But in this case, I am merely joking,
rather I tried to analyse its reasons for its Q1/FY2016 results.
Revenue
Revenue for Q1/FY2016 was RM53.29 million compared to preceding quarter
of RM57.77 million. It is a decrease of RM4.48 million which means business is
still on as usual. A slight increase or decrease in revenue is expected when a
quarter to quarter comparison is used.
Ringgit vs USD
The Ringgit were traded on average mostly between RM3.80 to RM4 during
the first quarter of 2016. As such, it has impacted its bottom line. In fact,
there was even a huge loss from foreign currency transaction. But we should
also note that the Ringgit started to weaken again the USD during the April and
has persistently traded above RM4 to RM4.10 despite the widely perceived view
that it correlated with crude oil.
But crude oil price has been recently touching or trading near its five
months high yet the Ringgit has actually weakened instead. Isn't the Ringgit
supposed to be trading higher in tandem with rising crude oil price? But it is
not, this time. What will happen to the Ringgit should crude oil price drop to below
USD 40 or even lower in the coming months?
Rising cash position
As Focus Lumber continues to make profit (although this time it is
making less money), it has a very good cash flow. Its current cash holding is
RM88 million (comprising cash RM62 million and Other Investment (OI) RM26
million) compared to RM74 million (cash RM57 million and OI RM17 million.
What is OI? According to its report, it is stated as in Money market
fund (unquoted in Malaysia). I believed its cash per share is around 85 sen.
Good Dividend Yield Stock
Focus Lumber is one stock that has been paying increasing dividend each
time it has reported a higher level of profits. It has been increasing
dividends payout from 6 sen to 8 sen and to 15 sen last year in tandem with
rising profits.
How would dividends for 2016 be? To get a good guess, one must first try
to get or analyse its eps for 2016. Assuming a conservative eps of 20 sen for
this year, I strongly believed a 10 sen to 12 sen dividend payout is there. At
current price of just RM1.91, this implies a dividend yield of more than 5 to
6% which is considered high when compared to the fixed deposit rate of bank.
The Dilemma of
Focus Lumber Shareholders
Many shareholders especially long term shareholders are now in a dilemma
of whether to cash out or hold on and ride through the storm. There is no one
who can tell us the answer of what will happen in the coming quarters results.
I am also in this dilemma with you as well. Will the share price recover
in the coming months if Focus Lumber can double up its eps of Q1/FY2016 in view
of a weakening Ringgit since April? What if the USD becomes even stronger and
push the Ringgit down to the RM4.20 to RM4.40 level? There are talks that the
US Federal Reserve will raise interest rate some times to come this year. All
these will have a huge impact the direction of the Ringgit which will
eventually has an impact on the bottom line of Focus Lumber.
At the time of writing, Focus Lumber is still trading at the RM1.90
+ levels, earlier having attained the
title of Number Biggest Loser on May 23 closing at RM2.07 following a massive
drop of 27 sen.
If you think that the coming months, the Ringgit will continue to stay
weaken and trade between RM4 to RM4.20 level against the USD, then it is better
to hold on to Focus Lumber.
But on the other hand, if you feel that the Ringgit will stay strong
and will continue to trade at RM3.80 to
RM4 levels in the coming months, then it might continue to impact the profit of
Focus Lumber and hence, another similar result as Q1 might invoke another round
of new selling again.
Personally, I feel the Ringgit will weaken in the coming months and
those export oriented stocks should resume its higher profits again based on
this exchange rate. But I don't have a crystal ball and am just judging this
based on my analysis and experience.
The next several coming months will reveal the truth. Stay on course?
You decide because in the investment world, it is
every man for himself.