Integrax
- All are
WINNERS!
Some of you
might have been disappointed that there was no posting from me especially the
Iast week of March. I managed to post one blog only last month as I normally
would have posted two. The reason is because of the Integrax Berhad's
issues, especially the last few days of the month.
My earlier
blog : Sometimes Up, Sometimes Down was due for posting on the last few
days in March. But events such as the late night announcement by Tenaga
Nasional Berhad that it has secured over 50% shares of Integrax Berhad
meant my pre-written blog had to be altered. Then as it was due to be posted
the next evening, came the news that our "David" Amin has
decided to throw in the towels and that also meant my just-altered blog must be
re-written again to reflect the latest situation.
As I said, I
needed time to digest all those successive nights of important announcement
regarding the situation of Integrax.
So now, it
is 100% clear that Tenaga - the "Goliath" has defeated minorities'
hero Amin - the "David" in this battle for Integrax Berhad.
Investors
must understand that right from the start, both had different agenda in this
battle. While Tenaga's mission is to secure control or total control of
Integrax (at all cost?), Amin's mission is to protect his and minorities'
interest in getting a higher price.
From reports
initially, Amin has argued that Integrax is worth at least RM5 per share and
any offer price near to that would be pleasing music to the ears.
It was
actually a battle of "buy from me at a higher price that is deemed good in
my opinion" rather than "I wound not be selling to you at all at any
price".
Interesting,
valuation is always a sticky point to judge and argue. While Perak Corp
Berhad's Independent Advisor values Integrax at RM3.25, Integrax's
Independent Advisor values it at RM3.66.
If you are
the offeror, having seen the first offer of RM2.75 rejected, you would surely
revised it to RM3.25 rather than RM3.66. Unless of course, Perak Corp decided
that they would sell their stakes to Tenaga at RM3.66 based on Integrax's
valuation. If Perak Corp had done that, would Tenaga revise the price to
RM3.66? That is a million ringgit question we all will never know.
Gracious in
defeat, Encik Amin
There is a
saying that if you think it can't be done in this way, then don't stand on the
way of someone else who think it can be done.
Obviously
Amin didn't see the same direction as the "new" boss Tenaga over the
future direction of Integrax. As such, it would be very uncomfortable in the
board's room when it comes to key decisions making. Amin would surely feel like
a lonely ranger in there.
So as a
gentleman, Amin makes the most honourable decision, that is selling all his
stakes of 24.8% to Tenaga. Is Amin a loser in this Integrax episode? No, in my
opinion, conceding defeat doesn't always means a person is a loser. In many
situation, saying sorry or admitting an error or defeat does not mean you are
the loser. In fact, you could be a winner for just admitting that!
From a
financial point of view, Amin would be pocketing a cool RM240 Million plus!
That is not a small amount of money. Amin also makes additional gains from his
investment in Integrax when he was buying aggressively around RM2.75 to RM3.00
during the first offer of RM2.75 from Tenaga.
Tenaga
crossed the 90% threshold!
Initially, I
thought that the most Tenaga can win in this battle is management control of
Integrax as Amin with his huge stakes would be the main stumbling block. But
now that out of the blue unexpectedly with Amin's stakes in as well, Tenaga
ended up with huge percentage of Integrax shares.
Tenaga has
managed to secure more than 90% shares from all the shareholders, then the
offer will become Mandatory Take Over for all. That means even if you refuse to
go the stock broking company and sign the necessary document forms to transfer
your shares, Tenaga will still be able to "track" you from the list
and send you a check, whether you like it or not.
We must bear
in mind that there are always hardcore "investors" who are daring
enough to hold on to their shares even if Tenaga is to delist Integrax. These
type of investors are those who believe that one day eventually, Integrax will
be relisted back with a richer valuations or Integrax corporated in a merger
excercise and listed in a different entity.
And I am not
ashamed to admit that I am one of those! Truth is I did not even make the trip
to the stock broking firm to sign the documents to sell my Integrax shares to
Tenaga! And I believe I won't be alone!
Tenaga's
closing date for the revised offer price of RM3.25 (of course to minus the 7.5
sen dividend paid out earlier) was April 13. Integrax was delisted on April 21,
2015.
All are
WINNERS in the end!
As this saga
of take over of Integrax came to an end, I must congratulate all investors as
most are winners in the end.
Tenaga got
what they want, Amin walked away with huge profits, other minorities groups
example Perak Corp also pocketed huge gains and that also included all other
shareholders who invested below the Revised Offer price of RM3.25.
Truly this
is one good battle where all are WINNERS in the end! How nice if there are
other future battles such as this. And there will always be. You have just
got to be able to spot-on very early .... like me.
Profits from
Integrax is ....
My total
original amount for investing in Integrax is RM33,231.65.
Dividends
received in year 2014 is RM900.00 (RM50 x 18,000 shares).
Dividends
received in year 2015 is RM1350.00 (RM75 x 18,000 shares).
Compulsory
acquitsition by Tenaga at RM3.175 x 18,000 shares is RM57,150.00.
Total to be
received is RM59,400.00 (from Tenaga and two dividends).
Total to be
received of RM59,400.00 to minus RM33,231.65 (original amount invested) shows a
profit of RM26,168.35 or a return of around 78% for an investment less than two
years.
Terima
Kasih, Tenaga for this windfall.